Top O'Keeffe's Alternatives and Similar Brands

  • #1 in 2 categories
  • Sharonville, Ohio
  • 2 to 10 employees

O'Keeffe's builds skincare aimed at very dry skin, with products including foot cream, lip balm, hand cream and moisturizing lotion. Tara O'Keeffe started the company in 1989 after weak nails led her to search for better remedies. The range targets problems such as cracked heels and rough hands.

O'Keeffe's alternatives

Why shoppers pick these instead of O'Keeffe's: each brand's key differences are listed under it.

TSCentral is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

  1. 1

    Bag Balm

    The multi-use balm, sold in a green tin for dry, cracked and chapped skin, was first created on a Vermont dairy farm. Bag Balm's formula uses simple ingredients with no sulfates or parabens, and the brand says it is safe...

    Why Bag Balm instead of O'Keeffe's
    • Suits anyone wanting one balm safe for both people and animals
    • Adds soap and lip balm to its green tin, while O'Keeffe's centres on creams
  2. 2

    AmLactin

    AmLactin designs skincare built around lactic acid, a gentle exfoliant used in its moisturizing lotions and creams. The range covers unscented options and products for dry skin. The products are sold online and also in physical stores and malls.

    Why AmLactin instead of O'Keeffe's
    • Targets bumpy skin with KP Bumps Be Gone cream, beyond O'Keeffe's hand and foot focus
    • Offers a firming cream and Bright & Smooth Serum, beyond O'Keeffe's hand and foot focus

    Top product: Intensive Healing Body Lotion

  3. 3

    Dionis

    Dionis started with goat milk skincare, and its honey lotion and men's body lotion are built around that base. Each formula is free of artificial fragrance and is intended for people with dry or dehydrated skin. The goat milk base...

    Why Dionis instead of O'Keeffe's
    • Adds scented goat milk hand creams; O'Keeffe's Working Hands feels thick and long-lasting
    • Suits men wanting a goat milk body lotion for dry or dehydrated skin

    Top product: Goat Milk Hand Cream

  4. 4

    Lubriderm

    Lubriderm's line was developed with dermatologists for dry skin, and it includes fragrance-free and lightly scented versions. Its body lotions use ingredients such as glycerin, shea butter and vitamin E. The brand says its formulas are clinically proven to moisturize...

    Why Lubriderm instead of O'Keeffe's
    • Compared with O'Keeffe's heavy-duty creams, Lubriderm offers body lotions for everyday use
    • Includes itchy skin and mature skin lotions alongside its daily moisture range

    Top product: Advanced Therapy Lotion

  5. 5

    Aquaphor

    From Germany's Beiersdorf, the company behind Eucerin, comes Aquaphor, a line of petrolatum-based healing ointments. The balms are used for dry, cracked skin, minor wounds and diaper rash, and the formulas contain no dyes or preservatives. Many people with sensitive...

    Why Aquaphor instead of O'Keeffe's
    • Aquaphor's daily lotion is pitched as hydrating without heaviness, versus O'Keeffe's thick working-hands creams
    • Made by Germany's Beiersdorf, while O'Keeffe's was started by pharmacist Tara O'Keeffe

    Top product: Aquaphor Healing Ointment

  6. 6

    Gold Bond

    Gold Bond makes body lotions, creams and overnight treatments aimed at dry and rough skin. Its Healing lotions combine several moisturizers, including shea butter and aloe, and unscented and daily formulas are also sold. The dermatologist-tested lotions are made for...

  7. 7

    Eucerin

    Eucerin's lotions are aimed at dry and sensitive skin, with unscented options and travel sizes among its formats. The line is built on dermatology, with products developed around hydration and protection for the skin barrier. Its moisturizers are often recommended...

  8. 8

    Udderly Smooth

    Urea-based moisturizers make up a large part of the Udderly Smooth line in several strengths. The brand began when a Midwest pharmacist developed the formula for dairy cows' udders, and farmers soon used it on dry hands. Products include a...

  9. 9

    Fruit of the Earth

    People looking for aloe vera gel for sunburn or dry skin will find it at the centre of Fruit of the Earth, a family-owned skin care company in Texas. Its line includes after sun aloe vera gels, aloe vera lotions...

  10. 10

    Dermasil

    Dermasil formulates moisturizing lotions, creams and treatments for dry and sensitive skin, including cocoa butter and unscented lotions. The brand has a pharmaceutical background and says its formulas are dermatologist-tested and cruelty-free. The lineup extends to exfoliating scrubs and an...

  11. 11

    Jergens

    Jergens designs moisturizing lotions, body butters and self-tanners for everyday dry skin. The brand has sold skin care since 1901 and is part of the Kao family of brands. Its shea butter lotions and Natural Glow self-tanners are among the...

  12. 12

    Vaseline

    In more than 140 nations worldwide, Vaseline provides care for the most delicate and sensitive skin, from newborns to older people. They specialize in a wide range of goods, including well-known brands like Vaseline Jelly, Aloe Vera, Cocoa Butter, and...

  13. 13

    Eos

    Eos makes a lip balm sold in a sphere-shaped tube, available in various flavors and scents. Its shea butter and beeswax lip balms are among its most recognized products. Eos body lotions, washes, body mists and shave products also carry...

  14. 14

    NIVEA

    NIVEA's facial skin care range includes moisturizing lotions, travel-size creams and dry skin primers. The brand has been making skin care products for over a century and offers products for many skin types. Its lineup also covers deodorants, serums and...

  15. 15

    Flexitol

    Flexitol makes skin care for the lips, hands, scalp and feet, plus lines for eczema-prone skin. Its foot treatment is formulated for very dry skin and cracked heels. Formulas across the range are designed for dehydrated and sensitive skin.

Where O'Keeffe's ranks

O'Keeffe's Shop Online