Top First & Main Alternatives and Similar Brands

  • Best rank #5 in Dimple Toy

First & Main started in 1994 in Chicago and has consistently produced some of the softest, most adorable stuffed animals at insanely affordable prices. The company understands the joy of gifting a stuffed animal and how much a child can get attached to them. Intending to put a smile on children's faces and uplift their moods, they have created a wide range of stuffed animals that are not only of the best quality but also affordable.

First & Main alternatives

Why shoppers pick these instead of First & Main: each brand's key differences are listed under it.

TSCentral is reader-supported: we may earn a commission when you shop through links on this page.

  1. 1

    Bearington Collection

    Giving someone an adorable and cuddly present is the best way to make them smile by bringing back childhood memories and conveying your sincere affection for them. This is what the Bearington Bears want to achieve. Designed for everyone, the...

    Why Bearington Collection instead of First & Main
    • Makes shaggy, bow-trimmed plush bears, compared with First & Main's embroidered heart bears
    • Fits shoppers wanting a classic gift bear for people of any age
  2. 2

    Basic Fun

    Basic Fun's line centers on action figures, plush stuffed animals and pre-school toys. The company also offers licensed characters such as Scooby-Doo, along with small toys for young children. Its range includes items for toddlers, and all of the items...

    Why Basic Fun instead of First & Main
    • Makes action figures and licensed characters such as Scooby-Doo alongside its plush
    • Serves buyers wanting a toy line for toddlers and pre-school play
  3. 3

    Mary Meyer

    Mary Meyer began making soft toys for babies and young children. Its line includes stuffed animals, baby blankets and rattles, all designed to be cuddly and gentle on skin. The toys are made with an emphasis on softness and safety...

    Why Mary Meyer instead of First & Main
    • Makes baby toys in minky and dot fabrics, versus First & Main's embroidered bears
    • Suits parents shopping for nursery toys, loveys and baby gifts

    Top product: Putty Bear

  4. 4

    Animal Adventure

    Animal Adventure makes soft plush toys, including stuffed animals, baby blankets and lion and dragon characters for young children. The Minnesota company produces squeezable designs. The toys are made from soft fabrics and built to last through daily play.

    Why Animal Adventure instead of First & Main
    • Makes Minnesota-made sitting plush bears, unlike First & Main's plaid details
    • Targets young children wanting soft stuffed animals and baby blankets

    Top product: Sitting Plush Teddy Bear

  5. 5

    Build-A-Bear Workshop

    Build-A-Bear Workshop lets children choose the filling, heart, eyes and outfit for stuffed animals before each toy is sewn. The St. Louis-based brand also sells clothing, sandals and small accessories for girls.

    Why Build-A-Bear Workshop instead of First & Main
    • Versus First & Main's embroidered bears, shoppers can watch each bear being stuffed
    • Based in St. Louis, offering personalised bears with a choice of voice

    Top product: Polar Bear

  6. 6

    Steiff

    Steiff makes plush toys, and its stuffed animals remain central to the brand. The company also sells children's socks, baby hats and other clothing for young kids. Its items use sturdy materials meant to last through years of play and...

    Why Steiff instead of First & Main
    • Makes German jointed bears with metal ear buttons, versus First & Main's plush
    • Appeals to collectors wanting mohair humpback bears, plus socks and baby hats
  7. 7

    GUND

    Baby GUND and classic GUND plush lines include teddy bears, stuffed animals and licensed characters. The company makes stuffed toys and sells them as gifts for babies, children and adults. Its catalog includes character plush, small plush sets and huggable...

    Why GUND instead of First & Main
    • Offers licensed character plush alongside shaggy beanbag bears and jumbo sizes
    • Gives gift buyers choosing classic bears for babies, children and adults
  8. 8

    GANZ

    GANZ offers personalized Christmas ornaments, bell ornaments and stuffed animals. The company is a wholesale supplier of gifts and home décor, and its products are sold through retailers in North America rather than directly to shoppers.

    Why GANZ instead of First & Main
    • Supplies North American retailers with wholesale gifts, home décor and personalized ornaments
    • Makes soft plush and bell ornaments, with cream and ivory bears with brown noses
  9. 9

    Manhattan Toy

    Manhattan Toy Company creates developmental toys for babies and toddlers, including plush toys, wooden toys and bath toys. Its lines include the Groovy Girls and Love, Stella dolls, which are sold with accessories. Its catalog also includes rattles and sensory...

    Why Manhattan Toy instead of First & Main
    • Compared with First & Main's teddy bears, offers sensory toys for early childhood play
    • Its developmental toys target babies and toddlers rather than gift bears
  10. 10

    Wild Republic

    Wild Republic designs realistic stuffed animals based on wildlife from around the world, including lion toys and sea turtle play sets. Each animal is sized and shaped to match its species, and many come with a fact sheet about the...

    Why Wild Republic instead of First & Main
    • Designs realistic stuffed animals sized and shaped to match each species
    • Includes fact sheets for many animals, versus First & Main's teddy bears
  11. 11

    Hallmark

    Hallmark makes greeting cards, thank you cards, and matching envelopes for birthdays, weddings and holidays. Its Christmas tree ornaments are a long-running collectible line, with some pieces dating back to 1973. Gift wrap and home decor are sold through its...

  12. 12

    Bear Factory

    Beverage-Air has remained a mainstay in the industrial freezer industry and has continuously improved its formulas to provide the best devices on the market. With their signature Cross Temp technology, you can easily switch between temperatures depending on your refrigerator...

  13. 13

    JAKKS Pacific

    WWE action figures and licensed plush sit at the center of the JAKKS Pacific catalog, which also covers dolls, diecast vehicles, electronic learning toys and activity sets. The company designs and markets toys, leisure products and writing instruments. Its items...

  14. 14

    TOMY

    Tomica Limited Vintage is TOMY's collector line of die-cast cars, launched in Japan and aimed at enthusiasts. TOMY also makes Trackmaster Thomas trains and Pokemon toys, along with nursery products such as Boon and The First Years. Its catalogue covers...

  15. 15

    Hasbro

    Hasbro designs action figures and toys tied to franchises such as Star Wars and Transformers, along with smaller toys for young children. The company, based in Pawtucket, Rhode Island, also works in entertainment content and sells collectibles aimed at fans...

Where First & Main ranks

First & Main Shop Online